Sail marketing brief · Saturday, November 7, 2026

Meta windows end Nov 6 (America/New_York): 7d Oct 31–Nov 6, prior 7d Oct 24–30, 28d Oct 10–Nov 6. Qualified = Zoho Lead converted to Contact (Shahar, 2026-10-05). Sail-named campaigns in Hotel 32 32 only. Hotel numbers include the Hospitality Show (THS) attendee ad sets (ended Nov 4). Restaurant spend is $0. Previous brief: Nov 6.

Headline. Meta hotel CPQL 7d $258.61 (5 converted / 85 forms, CPL $15.21, spend $1,293.06). Prior 7d $110.51 (11 / 97). 28d $158.63 (31 / 332, CPL $14.81, spend $4,917.42). Without THS ($364.98 7d, 0 forms): 7d $185.62, prior 7d $105.23, 28d $144.98.
Forms and CPL are steady (85 vs 97 forms; partial share 33%). The CPQL gap is still mostly Zoho lag: 1 conversion on Nov 6; 179 hotel leads since Oct 16 are still "Incoming"; 41 Meta forms from the last 7d look qualified but are not converted.
LinkedIn 7d: $544.83, 0 leads — all on the 2 THS attendee campaigns, COMPLETED Nov 5. No other LinkedIn campaign spent.

What matters today

  1. [23] Objections video — the due read. Since launch (Oct 27), all non-THS ad sets: $1,159.83, 104 forms (72 complete), 9 converted, $128.87 CPQL = 0.81× the $158.63 baseline. Flag brands 12/72 (17%). By ad set: US 2 $543 / 3 conv ($181, ad set 28d $195); Sun Belt $249 / 1 ($249, Video 2 in the same set: lifetime $73); Mexico Q. Roo $99 / 4 ($25); retargeting all-visitors $46 / 1; Caribbean $75 / 0, Indian Ocean $70 / 0, eblast $33 / 0, South Pacific $24 / 0 (all below the $317.25 pause bar). Call: HOLD everywhere. It is a little better than baseline overall, but 9 converted is a small sample and it misses the SCALE line (≤0.8× with ≥3). In Sun Belt it is weaker than Video 2 — no pause (below the bar). Re-read at 15+ converted.
  2. Zoho "Incoming" backlog: 179 hotel leads since Oct 16 with a real email, not converted and not rejected (169 yesterday, 84 on Oct 26). The Lead Magnet ad sets optimize on the Qualified event that conversion sends. Asked Nov 5; parked, not re-asked.
  3. No Meta ad meets the pause bar. Bar: lifetime spend ≥ $317.25 with 0 converted, or CPQL > $317.25 on ≥ $793.13. Live calls: 62 HOLD / 2 SCALE. Lifetime SCALE-level ads: Video 2 – Not Gradient in Sun Belt ($1,392 / 19 / $73), [01] STAR report in US 2 ($439 / 6 / $73), Video 2 (UTM fix) in eblast ($196 / 3 / $65), [23] in Mexico Q. Roo CBO ($56 / 3 / $19, small sample).
  4. CBO mix: US 2 took 91% of 7d CBO spend ($497, 1 conv); 28d $1,754 / 9 / $195 (1.23×, under the 1.5× flag bar). Mexico Q. Roo got 9% ($50, 2 conv; 28d $65 / 3 / $22; lifetime $834 / 20 / $42). The CBO is not feeding its cheapest set, but the sample is small — information only.
  5. Clarity: /report script errors 13 on 10 page views in 24h (9/9 yesterday, 12/10 Nov 5), error clicks 10 on /report. /report is the email-first form page. Recommendation: engineering check of the /report console errors. Not a decision.
  6. Email-first flow healthy: last 24h 11 emailed report jobs, 11 sent, 0 failed, 0 retried. Vercel env not read (Vercel CLI token still 403); flow is email by live behavior. No QA submission sent.

Hotel lead quality (CPQL first)

Platform · windowFormsConvertedCPLCPQLPartial shareLooks qualified, not convertedSpend
Meta · 7d Oct 31–Nov 6855$15.21$258.6132.9%41$1,293.06
LinkedIn · 7d Oct 31–Nov 600———0$544.83
Other (Google/organic) · 7d Oct 31–Nov 6295——34.5%12—
Meta · prior 7d Oct 24–309711$12.53$110.5134.0%37$1,215.60
LinkedIn · prior 7d Oct 24–3000———0$23.49
Other (Google/organic) · prior 7d Oct 24–30211——47.6%6—
Meta · 28d Oct 10–Nov 633231$14.81$158.6339.5%108$4,917.42
LinkedIn · 28d Oct 10–Nov 600———0$568.32
Other (Google/organic) · 28d Oct 10–Nov 61159——40.0%35—

Partial = hotel pick with no completed form. Restaurant Rank: exempt (CPL only); restaurant campaigns spent $0 in all windows. Under 10 converted = small sample.

Meta Sail campaigns

Campaign7d spend7d forms7d conv7d CPQL28d spend28d forms28d conv28d CPQL
Sail | Hospitality Show 2026 | Attendees | Booth 3314$364.9800—$423.0100—
Sail Lead Magnet — Retargeting$54.1560—$222.58152$111.29
Sail Lead Magnet — Geo ABO (winners)$292.11162$146.06$1,875.688614$133.98
Sail Lead Magnet - ABM$34.1800—$140.2961$140.29
Sail Lead Magnet$547.64613$182.55$2,255.8621814$161.13

Budget allocation watch (monitoring only)

Baseline = 28d Meta hotel CPQL $158.63. CBO flag rule: >20% of 7d CBO spend with 28d CPQL > 1.5× baseline, or 0 converted on > 1× baseline spend. No CBO flags today. US 2 holds 91% of 7d CBO spend; its 28d CPQL is $194.90 (1.23×, below the 1.5× bar). Indian Ocean and South Pacific are paused (0% of 7d).

CampaignAd setStatus7d spend (share)7d conv28d spend (share)28d conv28d CPQL
Sail Lead Magnet (CBO)US 2 — 35+ hard (A+A off) TESTACTIVE$497.20 (91%)1$1,754.10 (78%)9$194.90 · small sample
Sail Lead Magnet (CBO)Mexico - Quintana Roo (Cancun, Playa, Tulum)ACTIVE$50.44 (9%)2$64.83 (3%)3$21.61 · small sample
Sail Lead Magnet (CBO)Indian Ocean IslandsPAUSED$0.00 (0%)0$349.94 (16%)2$174.97 · small sample
Sail Lead Magnet (CBO)South Pacific IslandsPAUSED$0.00 (0%)0$86.44 (4%)0— · small sample
Geo ABO (winners)US Sun Belt (AZ/FL/NV) — 35+ hard (A+A off)ACTIVE$238.06 (82%)2$984.38 (52%)9$109.38 · small sample
Geo ABO (winners)Caribbean — DR + PR (Canada split out)ACTIVE$54.05 (18%)0$224.16 (12%)1$224.16 · small sample
Geo ABO (winners)Mexico - Quintana Roo (Cancun, Playa, Tulum)PAUSED$0.00 (0%)0$507.43 (27%)3$169.14 · small sample
Geo ABO (winners)Indian Ocean IslandsPAUSED$0.00 (0%)0$159.71 (8%)1$159.71 · small sample
ABMSail Lead Magnet — eblast audience (A+A off) - CopyACTIVE$34.18 (100%)0$140.29 (100%)1$140.29 · small sample
RetargetingRetargeting — all site visitors 30d, non-converters — 3ACTIVE$34.26 (63%)0$140.21 (63%)1$140.21 · small sample
RetargetingRetargeting — Lead 180d minus SubmittedForm — book a caACTIVE$19.89 (37%)0$82.37 (37%)1$82.37 · small sample
Hospitality ShowTHS attendees only (Instantly list) | Booth 3314 | endsACTIVE$233.52 (64%)0$233.52 (55%)0— · small sample
Hospitality ShowTHS attendees only (Instantly list) | Booth 3314 | endsPAUSED$131.46 (36%)0$189.49 (45%)0— · small sample

Overlap: 8.1% of CBO US 35+ 28d spend landed in FL/AZ/NV (6.6% in 7d), vs Sun Belt ABO 28d spend $984.38 at $109.38 CPQL.

Change log, last 7d (Sail ad sets):

Budget change readout: only one budget change in 28d — the THS ad set ($30 → $500/day on Nov 3) plus a $500 lifetime copy; both ended Nov 4 with 0 forms. No acquisition budget changed in 28d. No Sail ad set budget/status change since Nov 4. (A Nov 5 “SPRING SALE_SROTB_SAIL” entry matched on name only; it is a client campaign and is excluded.)

Creative performance (SCALE / HOLD / PAUSE)

CallAdAd set7d spend7d forms/conv28d spend28d forms/conv28d CPQL
SCALEVideo 2 - Not GradientUS Sun Belt (AZ/FL/NV) — 35+ hard ($51.584/1$596.7125/7$85.24
HOLD[05] Video Plain - Pre-flight checkUS 2 — 35+ hard (A+A off) TEST$96.1014/1$1,029.15116/4$257.29
HOLD[23] Video Plain - ObjectionsUS 2 — 35+ hard (A+A off) TEST$389.4943/0$539.8464/3$179.95
SCALE[23] Video Plain - ObjectionsMexico - Quintana Roo (Cancun, Play$50.243/2$55.485/3$18.49
HOLD (off)Video 2 - Not GradientMexico - Quintana Roo (Cancun, Play$0.000/0$256.7212/2$128.36
HOLD[23] Video Plain - ObjectionsUS Sun Belt (AZ/FL/NV) — 35+ hard ($168.876/1$247.807/1$247.80
HOLD[21] Video Plain - What if, side by sideUS 2 — 35+ hard (A+A off) TEST$8.901/0$131.723/1$131.72
HOLD[05] Video Plain - Pre-flight checkUS Sun Belt (AZ/FL/NV) — 35+ hard ($14.293/0$104.396/1$104.39
HOLDVideo 2 - Not Gradient (UTM fix)Sail Lead Magnet — eblast audience $5.310/0$89.786/1$89.78
HOLD (off)[01] Video Gradient - STAR reportIndian Ocean Islands$0.000/0$80.332/1$80.33
HOLDVideo 2 - Not GradientCaribbean — DR + PR (Canada split o$1.300/0$78.363/1$78.36
HOLD[21] Video Plain - What if, side by sideRetargeting — Lead 180d minus Submi$7.251/0$49.374/1$49.37
HOLD[01] Video Gradient - STAR reportUS 2 — 35+ hard (A+A off) TEST$1.850/0$48.216/1$48.21
HOLD[23] Video Plain - ObjectionsRetargeting — all site visitors 30d$27.382/0$46.067/1$46.06
HOLD (off)[23] Video Plain - ObjectionsMexico - Quintana Roo (Cancun, Play$0.000/0$43.223/1$43.22

Top 15 by 28d converted. Recent creatives (last 14d): the [23] Objections family (Oct 27) and the THS booth ads (Oct 28, Nov 3; ended Nov 4). Older [23] copies in paused campaigns show WITH_ISSUES — unchanged, not delivering. Flag brands: compare within an ad set; the audience drives flag share, not the creative.

LinkedIn (account 512779887)

API OK. Only the 2 THS attendee campaigns delivered (905914484 Videos, 905869934 Image): 7d $544.83 (28d $568.32), 0 leads; both COMPLETED (end 2026-11-05 04:59 UTC). Served-company pivot returned 0 rows for the window, so no exclusions applied and no ambiguous companies to list. No other campaign spent.

Clarity (sailtech.ai + marketing comparison)

Export API 200. 3d: 312 sessions (62 bots), dead clicks in 7.1% of sessions (67), rage clicks 0, script errors in 10.6% (39), avg scroll 78%. 24h: 85 sessions; /report script errors 13 on 10 views, error clicks 10; dead clicks /results 13 on 3 views, sailtech.ai/ 9 on 2, marketing-comp / 7 on 3, /hotel-marketing-agency 6 on 1.

Recommendations: (1) find and fix the /report console errors — it is the conversion step of the email-first flow; (2) check the dead-click targets on /report and /results (likely non-link competitor cards) and make them clickable or plainly static.

Research and creative

No new competitor pull today (Meta Ad Library API has no permission; last web check Oct 31). No new creatives rendered and no ads created: [23] reads HOLD and Video 2 still leads; no new angle has evidence behind it today.

Parked

Not re-asked today: Zoho Incoming queue (asked Nov 5; now 179); Edlen booth power (SAI-15069); Framer page drafts (SAI-16819); plus the earlier parked items in the Oct 31 brief. They return only when they are top 3 with fresh numbers.

Done: data pulls, brief. Attempted-failed: none. No status, budget, bid, targeting or ad change was made. Nothing published externally.